Picking a river cruise is a lot like picking a resort; the location is only half the story. Most people think about the river first—the Rhône, the Danube, the Rhine—but the truth is that the water doesn’t change. What actually defines your vacation is the brand you choose.
My husband and I recently sailed the Rhône on the Scenic Sapphire River Cruise out of Lyon. While we watched dozens of other ships pass by, it became very clear that not all experiences are created equal. In the world of river cruising, inclusions and service levels vary wildly. If you don’t choose carefully, you’ll end up nickel-and-dimed for things you assumed were part of the package
Why Scenic Stood Out to Us
On Scenic, the “All-Inclusive” label isn’t a marketing gimmick; it’s the reality of the trip.
-
Zero-Dollar Bar Tab: We never paid for a drink. Whether it was a coffee in the morning or a cocktail in the afternoon, it was included.
-
The “Little” Luxuries: We had a laundry service and two items pressed daily. It sounds small until you realize you can pack lighter and always look sharp for dinner without lifting an iron.
-
Butler Service: Having a butler wasn’t just fancy; it made the logistics of the trip effortless.
- Wellness on Board: Scenic is unique because of the Salt Therapy Lounge. After a day of walking, spending time there was the perfect way to reset.
Beyond the Bus: Tours That Actually Matter
One of the biggest misconceptions is that every river cruise line does the same tours. Scenic offers Freechoice, which means you aren’t just stuck on a standard bus tour. On the Rhône, we had some incredibly moving and unique experiences:
-
The French Resistance Walking Tour: In the town of Viviers, we heard stories of those who fought against the Nazi Occupation during WWII. It was educational, emotional, and deeply moving to learn about local heroism while walking the historic streets.
-
Guided Tour of Lyon: We traversed the “traboules”—secret passageways dating back to the 4th Century—and visited the Notre Dame Basilica. The vantage point from the top offers some of the best views across all of Lyon.
-
The “Enrich” Experience: Every sailing includes a Scenic Enrich event, and ours was unforgettable. We had a private classical concert at the Pope’s Palace in Avignon. After the doors closed to the public, we had one of the most visited sites in France all to ourselves for an exclusive performance inside the palace walls.
How the Brands Compare
| Feature | Scenic (Luxury) | AMA Waterways (Premium) | Avalon (Premium) | Viking (Contemporary) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Guest-to-Crew Ratio | 2.86:1 | 2.8:1 | 3.48:1 | 4.31:1 |
| Beverages | Truly All-Inclusive (inc. in-suite mini-bar) | Wine & Beer with Lunch & Dinner | Wine & Beer with Lunch & Dinner | Wine & Beer with Lunch & Dinner |
| Butler Service | Yes (All Suites) | No | No | No |
| Gratuities | Included | Not Included | Not Included | Included (onboard only) |
| Excursions | All Included (Freechoice & Enrich) | Some Included | Some Included | None Included |
| Airport Transfers | Yes | Only with AMA flight purchase | Only with Avalon flight purchase | Only with Viking flight purchase |
| Unique Feature | Salt Therapy Lounge | Pool, Cinema & Pickleball (select ships) | Pool or Whirlpool | Standard River Cruise |
